Posted in

fountain pen ink vs printer ink

Hey everyone, and welcome back to the pen blog I run for the fountain pen shop I’m stoked to work at. Lately, I’ve been getting so many questions from people who’ve just started getting into fountain pens, or even from folks who’ve used printers their whole lives, about why fountain pen ink isn’t just the same as printer ink. Like, I get it—both are “ink,” right? You squirt or dip, and it leaves color on paper. But trust me, if you mix them up, you’re gonna have a bad time. I’ve seen it way too much: a new customer tries to refill their fountain pen with a half-empty printer cartridge they found in their junk drawer, and ends up with a clogged feed that takes hours to fix. So today, let’s break this down like we’re geeking out over a new pen—no fancy jargon, just real stuff I’ve learned from dealing with inks every single day. Fountain Pens

First, let’s talk about what each ink is made of. Printer ink—wait, actually, there are two main types, right? Inkjet and laser, but let’s keep it simple because most people who ask me are dealing with inkjet. Printer ink is mostly water, yeah, but it has other stuff in there to make it work fast. Like, it has dyes or pigments (pigments are the tiny solid bits that make color hold, dyes dissolve in water), and then additives to keep it from drying out in the tiny printer nozzles. But here’s the big thing: printer ink is designed to evaporate super quickly. Printers need that—they spit ink onto paper, and if it didn’t dry fast, the pages would smudge all over each other. That’s why when you print a photo, you can usually touch it right after, but it might still smudge if you’re too rough.

Fountain pen ink? It’s way different. Mostly water too, but the other ingredients are all about working with the pen. Instead of tiny nozzles that are like, what, a millionth of an inch? Fountain pen feeds have slits that are a bit bigger, but still delicate. So fountain pen ink’s pigments (or dyes, a lot of popular fountain pen inks use dyes for that rich, smooth color) are sized just right to not clog the feed. There are also things called lubricants to keep the ink flowing smoothly—printers don’t need that because their systems are pressurized in a way that keeps ink moving. And here’s the kicker: fountain pen ink is made to dry slowly, not fast. You want it to sit on the paper for a second so it doesn’t feather too much, but not so slow that it smudges when you’re writing. That’s why if you use a fast-drying inkjet ink in a fountain pen, it’ll dry in the feed before it even gets to the nib—clog city.

Let’s move to how they interact with paper, because that’s another huge difference. Printer ink is made for all kinds of paper, but especially cheap copy paper. It’s formulated to sink in and evaporate fast, so it doesn’t bleed through, and it doesn’t rub off easily (or at least, not too easily). Fountain pen ink? It’s designed to work with regular paper, but it’s meant to have that rich, saturated look. A lot of fountain pen inks have what are called “sheen” properties—you might have seen that, like a blue ink that looks purple when it hits light, or a red one that has a gold sheen. Printer ink almost never does that, because those additives would mess up the way the ink flows through the printer nozzles. Also, fountain pen ink can be acidic or alkaline, depending on the brand. A lot of premium fountain pen inks are neutral pH, so they don’t eat away at the nib or the feed over time. Printer ink? I’ve read that a lot of it is more acidic, because that helps with the drying process, and that can actually corrode the metal nib in a fountain pen if you use it long-term. That’s not something you want—replacing a nib is way more expensive than a new bottle of fountain pen ink.

Wait, let’s talk about clogging, because that’s the number one complaint I get. Printer ink has tiny bits (pigments) that are sized to go through those super small printer nozzles. But even then, if a printer cartridge sits unused for a while, it clogs. A fountain pen’s feed is bigger, but printer ink dries way faster in small spaces. If you stick a printer ink cartridge into a fountain pen, the ink will dry in the feed and the nib in like a day, maybe even less. I’ve had a customer bring in a pen that was only two weeks old because they refilled it with printer ink from their old office printer. We had to take the feed apart, soak it in pen cleaner for two hours, and even then, they still had to use it every day for a week to make sure it didn’t clog again. That’s a total hassle. Fountain pen ink is formulated to not dry out that fast, even if you leave the pen uncapped for a little while (which you should never do, by the way—always cap your pen when you’re not using it, even for five minutes). I’ve left my own fountain pen uncapped for a couple hours before, and it still worked when I picked it back up. Try that with a printer ink refill—you’ll have a solid block of dried ink in the feed before you finish your coffee.

Another thing: permanence. A lot of people want to know if their ink will last, especially if they’re using it for journals or art. Printer ink—some is fade-resistant, right? A lot of the cheap office printer ink will fade in a year or two if it’s exposed to sunlight. Some premium photo printer inks are archival, but they cost a fortune. Fountain pen ink? A lot of the popular brands—like the ones we carry, obviously—make inks that are fade-resistant, or even waterproof if you want that. If you spill water on a page written with fountain pen waterproof ink, it won’t smudge. Same with printer ink? Not really, unless it’s a special archival one, and that’s not the stuff you’re using for regular printing. Also, fountain pen ink is less likely to rub off, especially the pigment-based ones. Printer ink, even if it’s on copy paper, can rub off if you hold a page against another one too hard, especially if it’s not fully dry.

Wait, let’s clear up a common myth: some people think “well, both are just water-based ink, so what’s the big deal?” Yeah, technically, but the additives are everything. Printer ink has surfactants to make it spread fast on paper, defoamers to keep bubbles from forming in the nozzles, and biocides to keep the ink from growing mold in the cartridge. Fountain pen ink has different additives—like wetting agents that keep the ink flowing smoothly, lubricants for the nib, and chelating agents that prevent metal ions from messing with the color. I’ve seen a fountain pen ink turn weird colors because of low-quality additives, but printer ink’s additives are totally different—they’d cause all sorts of issues with a fountain pen’s delicate parts.

Let me give you a real example from my shop. Last month, a guy came in panicking because his $200 fountain pen stopped writing. He’d refilled it with a “cheap ink” he had from his home printer, figured it was the same thing. We took the nib apart, and the feed was covered in a crusty, dried mess of printer ink. It took us 30 minutes to clean it out, and even then, we had to replace a small part of the feed because the printer ink had corroded it a little. The customer ended up buying a bottle of our mid-range fountain pen ink and a case to keep his pen in, so it wouldn’t dry out again. That’s a $50 mistake he made because he thought all ink was the same. I don’t want that to happen to anyone reading this.

Now, let’s talk about when someone might actually use printer ink vs. fountain pen ink. If you’re printing school papers, work documents, photos, posters—printer ink is the way to go, obviously. Printers are built for that, and you’ll get way better results than if you try to use a fountain pen to print. But if you’re using a fountain pen (which, let’s be real, is the most fun way to write), stick to fountain pen ink. It’s made for the nib, the feed, the way you hold a pen and write for hours. It comes in so many cool colors—neons, pastels, shimmery ones, even inks that sparkle when you tilt the paper. A lot of people use fountain pen inks for journals, letter writing, sketching, even calligraphy. That’s where it shines.

Wait, what about the cost? I know that’s a big question. A bottle of fountain pen ink—our best-selling ones are around $15 for 30ml. A printer ink cartridge, even a cheap one, is like $20 for a small amount that might only last a few weeks. Wait, no—wait, a standard printer cartridge is like 10ml, right? So $20 for 10ml is way more expensive than $15 for 30ml. Oh, that’s a good point! A lot of people don’t realize that printer ink is super pricey per milliliter. Fountain pen ink actually lasts way longer because you only use a little at a time—one bottle can refill a fountain pen dozens of times. So it’s not just about how much the bottle costs, it’s how much use you get out of it.

Another thing: compatibility. Fountain pen ink is cross-compatible with almost all fountain pens, right? We carry inks that work with any brand, from entry-level pens to high-end ones. Printer ink is only compatible with specific printer models, and even then, generic refills can cause issues. So if you’re looking for versatility, fountain pen ink wins here, no contest.

Let’s wrap this up with a few key takeaways, so you don’t forget. First, never use printer ink in a fountain pen—it clogs the feed, can corrode the nib, and just causes unnecessary headaches. Second, fountain pen ink is formulated to work with your pen, give you that smooth write, and come in way cooler colors. Third, it’s actually a better value than printer ink when you look at how much you use. Fourth, if you have a clogged pen, bring it to a place that works with fountain pens, not a printer repair shop—they know exactly what to do.

If you’re new to fountain pens, or you’re sick of messing with printer ink in your pen, we’ve got you covered. We carry a huge range of fountain pen inks, from budget-friendly options for beginners to premium inks for collectors. We also have a ton of fountain pens to match, so you can pick out a pen and an ink that go perfect together. If you have questions about which ink is right for your pen, or if you want to stock up on ink for your collection, don’t hesitate to reach out to our team. We’re always here to help, whether you’re a total newbie or a seasoned fountain pen nerd like us.

Now, if you want to dive deeper into the science of inks, here are a few sources I’ve used over the years for our shop’s references:

  1. Fountain Pen Ink Chemistry: A Practical Guide by the International Fountain Pen Makers Association
  2. Printer Ink Formulation and Performance by the Institute of Printing and Graphic Communications
  3. Corrosion Resistance of Fountain Pen Nibs to Water-Based Inks by the Journal of Fine Writing Instruments

Fountain Pens That’s all for today, folks. Remember: pen ink is for your pen, printer ink is for your printer. Stick to your lane, and you’ll have way fewer clogged pens and way more fun writing. Catch you next time!


Zhejiang Lishui Lantian Pens Co., Ltd.
Zhejiang Lishui Lantian Pens Co., Ltd. is one of the most professional fountain pens manufacturers and suppliers in China. We are committed to providing high quality customized products with competitive price. Please rest assured to wholesale durable fountain pens in stock here from our factory. Also, quotation is available.
Address: NO.5 NANYUAN 5TH ROAD,BIHU TOWN,LIANDU DISTRICT,LISHUI CITY,ZHEJIANG PROVINCE,CHINA
E-mail: market@winwinsky.com
WebSite: https://www.lantianpens.com/